EEOC Rescinds Criminal Background Check Guidance But Employers Still Have Obligations

Articles
A person sitting at a desk looking at a computer screen displaying an online criminal background check form.

The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) rescinded its 2012 Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions Under Title VII. This decision marks a significant shift in the agency’s approach to criminal background checks, but it does not eliminate employers’ obligations under federal, state or local law.

What Changed?

The EEOC's rescission removes the agency’s formal 2012 guidance document, which influenced employer practices for more than a decade. The guidance addressed how employers’ use of criminal history information could create liability under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It focused on both intentional discrimination and disparate impact theories of discrimination.

The 2012 guidance encouraged employers to avoid blanket exclusions based on criminal history and instead evaluate convictions using a fact-specific analysis based on the job sought, the nature of the offense and how much time has passed. This guidance also endorsed individualized assessments in many circumstances.

By rescinding the guidance, the EEOC removed its official interpretation of how employers should evaluate arrest and conviction records under Title VII. The agency has stated that the rescission reflects its view that enforcement should remain within the bounds of its statutory authority and consistent with the text of Title VII.

What Remains the Same?

This rescission does not change Title VII itself. Employers still may not make employment decisions based on race, national origin or other protected characteristics.

The EEOC has stated that employers do not have permission to engage in discriminatory practices simply because the guidance no longer exists. The agency continues to enforce Title VII’s prohibition against intentional discrimination, including situations where criminal history requirements serve as a proxy for race or national origin discrimination.

This rescission also does not eliminate existing court decisions addressing criminal background checks. Federal courts may continue to evaluate criminal-history screening practices under Title VII using established legal principles.

In addition, this rescission does not affect employers’ obligations under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act or the many state and local laws that regulate criminal background checks. Employers remain subject to those requirements regardless of the EEOC's decision.

As a practical matter, many employers will likely continue using screening processes similar to those developed under the 2012 guidance because those practices have become deeply integrated into their hiring procedures and compliance programs.

California Requirements Remain in Effect

For California employers, the EEOC's action does not alter existing state-law obligations.

California’s Fair Chance Act restricts when and how covered employers may consider criminal history information during the hiring process. In most circumstances, an employer may not ask about or consider conviction history before extending a conditional offer of employment.

California law also limits the types of criminal history information employers may consider. Employers generally may not rely on arrests that did not result in conviction, participation in diversion programs or certain older marijuana-related offenses.

After making a conditional job offer, an employer may review conviction history. However, before denying employment based on a conviction, the employer must perform an individualized assessment to determine whether the conviction has a direct and adverse relationship to the specific duties of the position.

That assessment generally considers:

  • The nature and gravity of the offense or conduct;
  • The time that passed since the offense or completion of the sentence; and
  • The nature of the job sought.

If the employer preliminarily decides that the conviction justifies withdrawing the offer, California law requires a notice process that gives the applicant an opportunity to respond before the decision becomes final.

California regulations provide additional requirements regarding individualized assessments, adverse action procedures and recordkeeping obligations. In addition, many jurisdictions have enacted their own fair chance ordinances.

Even though the EEOC has rescinded its guidance on criminal background checks, employers must still comply with all federal, state, and local laws.

CalChamber members can learn more about the latest developments of California’s Fair Chance Act, review local ordinances and conducting background checks as part of the hiring process in the HR library. Not a member? Enjoy a free 7-day trial today!

Author

Portrait of Shannon N. Claire
Shannon N. ClaireEmployment Law Subject Matter Expert
View Full Bio

Share with Others!

Schedule a Demo

CalChamber is committed to protecting and respecting your privacy, and we’ll only use your personal information to administer your account and to provide the products and services you requested from us. From time to time, we would like to contact you about our products and services, as well as other content that may be of interest to you. If you consent to us contacting you for this purpose, please tick below to say how you would like us to contact you:

You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For more information on how to unsubscribe, our privacy practices, and how we are committed to protecting and respecting your privacy, please review our Privacy Policy.

By clicking Schedule my demo below, you consent to allow calchamber.com to store and process the personal information submitted above to provide you the content requested.

Website Feedback